Comparing Gold IRA Companies: 10 Due-Diligence Checks Before Choosing a Dealer

INDEPENDENT RESEARCH GUIDE
By Steve Maitland, Publisher & Research Analyst
Updated 30 September 2026 • 12 minute read

Choosing a precious-metals dealer is only one part of establishing a self-directed IRA. The dealer supplies the metals, while the IRA trustee or custodian administers the account. Comparing each party's role, charges and written terms can help investors identify avoidable costs and operational risks.

Before initiating a transfer or committing capital, it helps to use a consistent evaluation framework. This guide outlines 10 practical checks covering the dealer, custodian, depository, product pricing and the process for eventually selling or distributing the metals.

This checklist reflects the methodology Maitland Wealth uses when reviewing the companies included in our Gold IRA company comparison.

Editorial Note: This guide provides an educational framework for comparing self-directed IRA providers. It does not constitute financial or tax advice. Investors should independently verify all fee schedules, storage arrangements, and IRS compliance protocols directly with any provider before transferring retirement funds.

The 10-Point Gold IRA Due-Diligence Checklist

1 Verify IRS-Approved Custodian Relationships

An IRA must have an eligible trustee or custodian. The precious-metals dealer normally handles the purchase or sale of the metals, while the trustee or custodian administers the IRA, maintains records and reports relevant transactions.

What to check: Ask for the legal name of the proposed trustee or custodian, its current fee schedule and an explanation of its relationship with the dealer. Confirm the appointment directly with the custodian rather than relying only on the dealer's description. Read our complete Gold IRA custodian due-diligence checklist for additional checks.

2 Evaluate Storage and Depository Security

IRA-owned precious metals are subject to the federal collectibles rules and custody requirements. IRC Section 408(m)(3) provides exceptions for certain coins and bullion, while qualifying bullion must be in the physical possession of a trustee described in the statute. Arrangements promoted as personal or home storage can create serious tax risk. See our IRS Code Section 408(m) analysis for the statutory detail.

What to check: Obtain the name and address of the depository, evidence of applicable insurance and a written description of how ownership is recorded. Ask whether storage is commingled or segregated, what each option costs and how metals are identified and released. Do not assume that a familiar depository name removes the need to examine the actual agreement.

3 Assess Fee Transparency (Flat vs. Tiered)

Self-directed IRAs inherently carry ongoing administrative and vaulting costs. However, how those fees are structured varies wildly between companies. Fee drag can significantly impact the long-term performance of your retirement portfolio.

What to check: Compare whether administrative and storage charges are flat, tiered, or asset-based, and calculate how each structure would affect the account at the allocation size you are considering. Review our Gold IRA Fees Guide for a detailed breakdown of how to evaluate long-term carrying costs.

The "Hidden Markups" Check

Beyond administrative fees, the transaction price may include a dealer premium or spread. Ask for the spot price, unit price, total price and estimated resale value for each proposed product in writing. Compare identical products at roughly the same time because market prices move continuously.

4 Confirm IRS-Approved Metals Expertise

Not every gold, silver, platinum or palladium product qualifies for an IRA. IRC Section 408(m) contains specific coin exceptions and minimum fineness requirements for qualifying bullion. For example, most qualifying gold bullion must meet a .995 fineness standard, although certain listed coins, including American Gold Eagles, are covered by a separate statutory exception.

What to check: Obtain the exact product name, mint, weight and fineness before authorising the trade, and ask the custodian to confirm eligibility. Acquisition of a non-exempt collectible by an IRA is generally treated as a distribution under Section 408(m)(1), which can create tax consequences. Use our Gold IRA approved-metals guide as a starting point, then confirm each product with the custodian.

Understand Collectibles, Premium Coins and Eligibility

If a representative recommends premium, numismatic or proof coins, ask whether the specific product is IRA-eligible and compare its dealer markup with standard bullion. Eligibility and pricing are separate considerations, and higher premiums can affect the amount of metal purchased for a given allocation.

5 Examine Buyback Policies and Liquidation Friction

A retirement account is a long-term vehicle, but metals may eventually need to be sold or distributed. Traditional IRA owners can also become subject to Required Minimum Distribution rules, while Roth IRA owners are generally not required to take lifetime RMDs from their own Roth IRAs under current federal rules.

What to check: Ask for the company's buyback policy in writing. Compare the terms, as prices are not guaranteed and dealers generally are not legally obligated to repurchase metals simply because they advertise a programme. Ensure you obtain the specific settlement terms, pricing methodology, and liquidation mechanics before opening an account.

6 Check Minimum Investment Thresholds

Dealer minimums are commercial policies rather than IRS requirements. They can differ between IRA and cash purchases and can change without notice.

What to check: Confirm the current minimum in writing and consider how fixed annual custodian and storage charges affect the account at the amount you intend to allocate. A higher minimum does not, by itself, demonstrate better service or suitability.

7 Analyze Customer Reviews and Complaint History

Customer feedback can reveal recurring service issues, but review platforms are not a substitute for examining contracts, fees and trade documents. Ratings may also change and can be affected by each platform's collection and moderation methods.

What to check: Look beyond testimonials on the company's own website. Review the current Better Business Bureau profile, relevant state regulatory records and other independent review sources. Focus on repeated complaint themes, the company's responses and whether the underlying issue appears to have been resolved.

8 Evaluate Educational Resources vs. Sales Tactics

Physical metals have different pricing, custody and liquidity considerations from publicly traded securities. Clear education can help, but it should not be used to disguise pressure-based selling.

What to check: Does the company explain price volatility, dealer spreads, storage charges and possible resale losses, or does it rely on fear-based claims and artificial deadlines? Take time to review the documents and, where appropriate, consult an independent tax, legal or financial professional.

9 Verify the Rollover and Transfer Process Support

A self-directed IRA may be funded through a contribution, an IRA-to-IRA trustee-to-trustee transfer or an eligible rollover from a workplace retirement plan. These methods are not interchangeable, and plan restrictions and tax rules can differ.

What to check: Ask the receiving custodian to explain which method applies. An IRA-to-IRA trustee-to-trustee transfer is different from a direct rollover from an employer plan. If funds are paid to the individual, the 60-day rollover rules, withholding and one-rollover-per-year limitations may become relevant depending on the transaction. Review our Gold IRA rollover guide and confirm the process with the custodians or a qualified tax professional.

10 Review Operating History and Industry Longevity

Operating history can provide more evidence about how a company has handled customer service, complaints and changing market conditions, but longevity alone does not prove financial strength or good conduct.

What to check: Confirm the company's legal name, formation date, principal address and relevant registrations. Check whether its advertised trading history matches public records, and evaluate recent conduct alongside the length of time it has operated.

Quick Summary: The Due-Diligence Grid

1. Custodians

Are they partnered with regulated, independent trust companies?

2. Storage

Do they use insured depositories? Are segregated options available?

3. Fees

Are administrative and storage fees flat or scaled? Are markups clear?

4. Compliance

Does the custodian confirm each product's eligibility under Section 408(m)?

5. Buybacks

Have you requested and evaluated written liquidation terms?

6. Minimums

Does their required minimum investment match your portfolio size?

7. Reputation

What is their track record on independent platforms like the BBB?

8. Culture

Do they prioritize education, or use high-pressure sales tactics?

9. Logistics

How effectively do they coordinate the rollover or transfer process?

10. Longevity

Do public records support the company's stated history and identity?

Ready to Compare Providers?

Use these checks when reviewing our provider comparison and when requesting written quotations directly from dealers, custodians and depositories.

Compare Gold IRA Companies
Steve Maitland

Steve Maitland

Publisher & Research Analyst

Steve Maitland leads the research and editorial direction at Maitland Wealth, focusing on clear sourcing, fee transparency and practical due diligence for readers researching precious-metals retirement accounts.

Scroll to Top